Controversy Surrounds Preview Clip
The release of a preview clip from the highly anticipated fourth season of “The Chosen” has sparked controversy, particularly due to its portrayal of a conversation between Jesus and Judas Iscariot—an interpretation some critics deem “unbiblical.”
Dallas Jenkins, the showrunner, unveiled this intriguing scene last week, teasing audiences with what’s to come in the April 2025 premiere.
The segment captures a crucial moment where Jesus and Judas engage in dialogue that hints at the latter’s impending betrayal.
In this emotionally charged exchange, Jesus presents a critical choice to Judas regarding his loyalty, urging him to reflect on where his true devotion lies.
Judas, in turn, insists that his greatest ambition is to continue following Jesus.
Their interaction is marked by intimacy when Jesus takes Judas’s hand and expresses a desire to pray for him, while also requesting a brief moment of solitude.
Mixed Reactions from Pastors
Responses to the clip have flooded social media, with backlash particularly evident among some pastors who feel the series strays too far from biblical accuracy.
One pastor from Arizona pointed out that the Bible does not indicate any prayer from Jesus for Judas, referencing John 17:12, which labels Judas as “the son of perdition”—a term he interprets as signaling a predestined betrayal.
Similarly, a Florida-based pastor questioned the disparity between the biblical accounts and the show’s portrayal, asserting that the series often misaligns with the sacred texts.
Shane Idleman, lead pastor of Westside Christian Fellowship, acknowledged that “The Chosen” does take creative liberties but voiced concern over the potential controversy surrounding the scene’s dialogue.
Support and Artistic Interpretation
A critical blog focused on discernment described the moment as “super unbiblical,” reflecting a strong stance against the show’s narrative choices.
Yet, not everyone shares this viewpoint.
Supporters argue that even if the dialogue diverges from scripted Scripture, it still captures the essence and overarching themes the series aims to convey.
Jenkins, whose father, Jerry B. Jenkins, authored the “Left Behind” series, has previously responded to anxieties about deviations from biblical text.
He noted that only around five percent of the series’ content comes directly from Scripture, emphasizing that while the Bible provides the foundation, much of the narrative is inspired by creative interpretation.
He cautioned about the dangers of artistic freedom, stressing the need to preserve the core of Jesus’s character and teachings as outlined in the Gospels.
Jenkins has urged viewers to see “The Chosen” as a companion to the Bible rather than a replacement, encouraging deeper exploration of Scripture following each episode.
Source: Christianpost
